This interview is with L Alan
Winters, one of the authors
of Trade Liberalization and Poverty: A Handbook. This
Handbook, published with the Department for International
Development (DFID), examines how openness to trade is a key
element of economic policy and how our concerns about the
world's poor should affect our attitude towards and
implementation of trade liberalization.
1. Is
your backing for free trade as enthusiastic as one might
expect? Who is right, protesters or economists?
[James
Morgan]
...
Free trade is good for you…the handbook is
realistic…but recognizes that pulling down trade barriers
isn’t the only thing…invest in social, physical
infrastructure
...
[L. Alan Winters]
2.
Do
the LDCs have the capacity to liberalize and do those other
things - provide the necessary physical and social
infrastructure at the same time?
[James
Morgan]
Trade liberalization helps in all circumstances…best
of combined with other policies...should be there anyway ... they
become more relevant ...
[L. Alan Winters]
3. Trade
liberalization makes winners and losers. But in the developing
world the losers are especially hard hit
[James
Morgan]
...
Liberalize sensibly, there won’t be many
losers…but they can be helped...change crops…market better…better
regulations, public services ...
[L. Alan Winters]
4. You
emphasize the importance of agriculture but power is in the
towns and they demand protection
[James
Morgan]
Poverty alleviation policies have to concentrate on the
rural... spillovers ... poor spend 50-60% of income on food ...
[L. Alan Winters]
5. Anti-dumping
causes the most anger. Are there no cases of unfair trade?
[James
Morgan]
...
Maybe 3% of cases ...those can be dealt with by
other methods ... danger not just US, EU ... LDCs may start and
thus damage their own people ...
[L. Alan Winters]
6. Is
it true that developing countries always lose on intellectual
property protection?
[James
Morgan]
...
Very small, very poor ones yes ... India, Brazil
no ... but much work needed on who can gain ...
[L. Alan Winters]
7. In
the developed world people feel they want to help those who
suffer poor employment and environmental conditions. Is there
not a case for standards?
[James
Morgan]
...
Maybe, but have to be appropriate and adopted
willingly ... dangers of partial coverage ... cannot be imposed by
trade sanctions ...
[L. Alan Winters]
8. You
suggest that post-September 11 conditions could improve the
chances of the proposed new trade round
[James
Morgan]
...
Becoming clear that the world is a community ... cooperation the sensible
way ... trade policy can help heal the wounds.