|
|
Euro
vs. Dollar
From Alogoskoufis and Portes (1991) to Bergsten (1997), commentators
have considered why reserve currency status matters: international
seigniorage, benefits for ‘home’ financial institutions, relaxation
of the ‘external constraint’ on macroeconomic policy, the role of
the region in international institutions, effects on macroeconomic
policy coordination, and the wider consequences of exercising
‘currency hegemony’. Portes and Rey use a new model and new data to
assess how far the euro will take on this role; to measure the effects
of alternative scenarios on welfare in the main world regions; and to
consider carefully the transition period as the international monetary
system adjusts to the euro.
Speaking in London at the launch of EMU: Prospects and Challenges
for the Euro, Portes said:
- The development of euro financial asset markets and network
(‘thickness’) externalities among euro users in forex markets
will support the euro’s role as an international currency. As euro
securities markets become deeper and more liquid and transactions
costs fall, euro assets will become more attractive, so the use of
the euro as a vehicle currency in forex markets will grow; the two
effects interact, and that synergy will bring the euro to challenge
the dollar.
- Previous work focused on private invoicing behaviour, official
reserve holding behaviour, and the use of the euro as an anchor
currency (pegging) – according to the new analysis, all these will
be secondary to the financial and forex market interactions.
- The Portes-Rey calculations show that if financial market
integration in Europe progresses sufficiently, the
‘fundamentals’ of international trade and investment could
support either a ‘medium euro’ or a ‘big euro’ scenario. In
both, the euro would replace the dollar as the main international
currency for financial asset transactions (except between the US and
Asia), but only in the ‘big euro’ scenario would the euro also
take on the forex market vehicle currency role.
- The consequence could be a welfare gain of 0.5% of GDP (annually)
for Europe, with a similar loss for the US – as well as the other
economic and geopolitical attributes of the ‘hegemonic’ world
currency.
- The transition period will see substantial portfolio shifts from
dollar-denominated into euro-denominated assets, possibly creating
excess demand for the latter. That would favour a ‘strong’ euro.
- To promote the internationalisation of the euro, European
policy-makers should focus their efforts on integrating European
capital markets. Deregulation and policy harmonisation (for example,
in government bond issuing) as well as private market initiatives
could enhance the liquidity, breadth and depth of these markets. So
measures that would improve the financial environment for savers and
investors in the euro region would also support the euro’s
challenge to the dollar.
- The early period could see considerable instability associated
with the emergence of the euro, especially if the United States were
to resist any decline in the international status of the dollar. The
European authorities will have to take account of these
instabilities and exchange-rate pressures in setting their monetary
policies, and this may make simple policy rules inadvisable. Better
international macroeconomic policy coordination may be necessary to
mitigate the destabilising effects.
Notes for Editors:
We gratefully acknowledge the support of Salomon Smith Barney
in launching this book.
EMU: Prospects and Challenges for the Euro is a
special issue of the review, Economic Policy: A European Forum. It
contains revised versions of the papers presented to the Twenty-Sixth
Economic Policy Panel Meeting held in Bonn on 17/18 October 1997, with
the support of the Zentrum für Europäische Integrations-forschung. The
Economic Policy Panel meets twice annually to discuss papers that are
specially commissioned by the editors to provide timely and
authoritative analyses of the choices confronting policy-makers. The
articles use the best of modern economic analysis, but are easily
accessible to a wide audience and highly readable. Each paper is
discussed by a rotating Panel of distinguished economists whose comments
are published to provide the reader with alternative interpretations of
the evidence and a sense of the liveliness of the current debate.
Economic Policy is published in association with the European
Economic Association for the Centre for Economic Policy Research, the
Center for Economic Studies of the University of Munich and the Département
et Laboratoire d’Economie Théorique et Appliquée (DELTA), in
collaboration with the Maison des Sciences de l’Homme.
Richard Portes is Professor of Economics at London Business School
and President of the Centre for Economic Policy Research. He is a Senior
Editor of Economic Policy.Hélène Rey is a lecturer in economics at the
London School of Economics.
For further information about CEPR, please contact Rita Gilbert,
External Relations Manager, Tel 44 20 7878 2917; Fax 44 20 7878 2999;
Email rgilbert@cepr.org
EMU: Prospects and Challenges for the Euro
Embargo date: 00.01 20 April 1998
Blackwell Publishers for CEPR, CES and DELTA
ISBN: 0631 209972
£39.50/$64.95
Available From:
Marston Book Services, Direct Sales Department, PO Box
269, Abingdon, OXON, OX14 4YN, UK
and
Blackwell Publishers
350 Main Street, Malden, Cambridge MA 02148-9933, USA
Tel: (toll free 800) 216 2522 Fax: (+718) 388 8210
|
|